PEOPLE FIRST LANGUAGE
WORDS WITH DIGNITY FOR PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES
APRIL 19, 2011
CAROLYN PHILLIPS: Okay, everyone. We're going to
go ahead and get started. And we're doing something a
little different today.
Liz and I are usually side by each when we're doing
this, but we're in different locations. And so we're going
to be going back and forth and doing this in a virtual way,
even more virtually than it already is.
And so we're really glad that all of you are with
us. This is a very, very important topic. And I'm going
to, in just a few minutes, cover why we chose this topic
and why we had people request this topic for us to cover.
But, Liz, do you want to give them a little
introduction to our webinar room so that everybody will
know how to navigate this more effectively?
LIZ PERSAUD: Thank you, Carolyn. And I absolutely
miss being beside you too.
Hey, everyone. This is Liz with the Pass It On
Center. And hopefully you can hear me loud and clear. If
not, please feel free to type into the public-chat area,
and I'll do my best to speak a little bit louder.
But again, welcome. And thank you so much for
joining us today. It looks like we've got a lot of people
jumping on actively, and we really appreciate that.
And I'm very excited about the topic that we've got
here for you guys, People First Language, and just really
words with dignity when talking about or speaking with
people with disabilities.
As Carolyn said, she'll jump in in a few minutes
and mention why we're kind of taking a little break this
month as far as not talking specifically about AT reuse but
kind of jumping into this topic.
But before we do that, I'd like to do a little bit
of housekeeping rules and just kind of do a brief intro of
the webinar room.
So hopefully everyone can see the slides that we
have up. It's the title slide with the Pass It On Center
logo and the title of this webinar. If you have any
difficulty with that, please feel free to let us know.
You can also refresh your screen to make sure that
you are able to see it. And what you to do is, over on the
left-hand side at the very top, there is two green arrows
that kind of look like a little bit of a recycling symbol.
And you can just click on that, and that will refresh your
screen.
If you need to adjust any of your accessibility
options, what you can do is go into "Options." There's a
tab for "Accessibility," and you can adjust your screen
settings. And if you're using any type of screen reader or
anything like that, it's pretty self-explanatory. It can
help you with that as well too.
Over on the right-hand side we have a public-chat
area. Some of you can see, if you jumped on a few minutes
ago, that we've been kind of typing back and forth, saying
hello to some folks and doing some little tests on whether
the chat is coming in.
So feel free, if you don't have a microphone, to
type into the white box. It's just underneath where the
icon says "Emoticon" where you can do all those fun smiley
faces and things like that.
But feel free to type in any questions or comments
or anything that you'd like to connect with us on if you
don't have a microphone right there.
Underneath that you can see the list of -- just as
Carolyn just put up her smiley face.
And we've got Cheryl G. just saying "Just testing.
1, 2, 3."
Thank you, guys, so much.
Underneath that we've got a list of the moderators
that are on here: Myself, Kimberly Griffin, Carolyn
Phillips, and Caroline from ATIA, and the list of
participants underneath.
If you do have a microphone and you are not using
the typing for public-chat area, what you need to do when
you speak is to hold down the "Control" key on your
keyboard.
You need to hold down the control key as you're
speaking. And as soon as you're finished, if you could
release that "Control" key so that Carolyn, myself, or
anyone else who has any questions or comments can jump on
and speak as well too. So again, just hold the "Control"
key down, and as soon as you're finished, just let go.
We want to say hello to Kimberly Griffin. She's
our transcriptionist. She joins us on all of our webinars
for Pass It On Center.
We really appreciate you being on here today,
Kimberly.
But Kimberly is going to be transcribing this
webinar. This webinar is also recorded. So if you give us
about three to four weeks, we will have this up on the Pass
It On Center website underneath the "Webinars" tab. And
you guys will be able to access that and use it as well and
be able to listen to it and share it with your co-workers
and community as well too.
We wanted to let you know that we have credits
available for this webinar. We're very, very happy to be
able to offer this to all of you just as another incentive
to join us on these webinars.
We're able to offer CEUs, continuing education
units. We do this through the AAC Institute. So a big
thank you to the AAC Institute.
So if any of you are interested in getting CEUs,
what you'll need to do is just log on to the AAC Institute
website. And it's aacinstitute.org. You can get the link
off the Pass It On Center website under the "Webinars" page
as well too. You're able to get all the information there
to register and receive your certification.
Now, I just want to put a little tickler note in
there that we are working with the AAC Institute. They've
got all of our information for webinars. They've just had
some administrative issues on the website, and so they're
working to get all of the information up on the website.
I've gotten a lot of e-mails behind the scenes that
you haven't seen the webinar information up already. Just
be patient. And again, if you have any troubles with that,
please feel free to send me an e-mail or give me a call,
and I'd be more than happy to intervene or help in any way
I can.
We are also offering CRCs -- we are very excited
about being able to do that -- CRCs for this webinar. And
if you are interested in CRCs, if you haven't already,
please send me an e-mail with your name, organization,
city, state, and the e-mail address to best correspond with
you. And what I will do is, after this webinar in the next
few days, I will e-mail your verification form.
So my e-mail address is liz@passitoncenter.org.
And you can send information about CRCs, any questions
about the webinar to me right there.
And I see that Cheryl G. has a question. And
thanks, Cheryl G.
She says, "Is there a test or any other step to
obtain CRC credits?"
If you are able to -- if you have your CRC
certification, you should be able just to send me the
information, and I'll send you the CRC verification form.
And it has the instructions there to go ahead and turn that
in for you to receive your CRC credits.
I don't know if Carolyn wants to jump on about
anything with CRCs as well. But I think that's pretty much
what you just need to do.
We also just have -- if everyone could actually
give -- type into the public-chat area -- excuse me -- with
your name and information, the organization that you're
with, what that does is help us to build our roster to
offer these credits. So that's something that's very
important.
So just as I'm kind of doing these housekeeping
tips here, just type in your first, last name and
organization that you're with. That will, again, just
really help us out.
The next slide here says "Help us improve." And
we'll actually put this information up at the end of the
webinar as well too, but -- just as Carolyn did.
Thank you, Carolyn. Thanks, everyone.
But we'll actually put this up again at the end of
the webinar. But again, this helps us to improve our
webinars, to make sure that we're covering the topics that
you guys want to hear, that you need to hear.
This is some information that we've received on our
webinar feedback on this topic that we're providing with
you today. And this also helps us to provide more -- to
continue offering those credits to you.
So again, after the webinar, if you could just jump
on the SurveyMonkey, fill out the webinar evaluation. It
shouldn't take you more than five minutes to do so. And
just give us feedback on this webinar and any other
webinars that you have any information on.
I also wanted to give a quick shout out to Caroline
Van Howe from ATIA. She's joining us today under the
"Moderator" section.
Hello, Caroline. And thank you so much for joining
us on this webinar today.
Wanted to let everyone know that the Pass It On
Center will be having an AT reuse substrand at ATIA Chicago
of this year, 2011, and also in Orlando, 2012.
This is something that we've done in previous years
past. And what we're doing this year is actually tying AT
reuse into the existing strand. So we're very excited
about that.
Pass It On Center will be sending more information
out as we are able to formulate and organization more on
the ATIA AT Reuse strand for Pass It On Center. So please
be looking out for that.
Also wanted to let everyone know that the call for
papers for ATIA is still open. It's open until April 29th.
So you've got just a few more days to get all that
information in. And if you have any questions, I'm sure
you can e-mail Caroline Van Howe and also visit the ATIA
website, which is ATIA.org.
So I think that's pretty much set for the
introduction. And I will release the mic and pass it over
to my good friend Carolyn Phillips.
Here you go, Carolyn.
CAROLYN PHILLIPS: Excellent. So glad that y'all
are with us, as we said before.
I just hit the refresh button, and so everybody
should be seeing a slide right now that says "Why are we
here today?" And let me know if you do see that slide.
UNKNOWN SPEAKER: Yes, I see it.
CAROLYN PHILLIPS: Excellent. Okay.
So this is a topic that Liz and I have talked about
for years, the whole concept of people first language,
person first language. It's not necessarily something that
Liz and I came up with.
Actually, we have peers all over the country that
have been working on and leading the way with this whole
movement of using words with dignity and really thinking
more about our language.
And so we're happy to continue that and join forces
with folks like Paraquad and our peers in Kansas and folks
like Kathie Snow, who have been so visionary in the way
that they use language and have helped all of us start
using language in a more thoughtful way.
And part of why we selected this topic for the Pass
It On Center strand for our webinars is because a lot of
folks, they produce materials; they put out brochures; they
name their organizations, what have you. And sometimes the
name of the organizations or the materials that we print
out could also be somewhat offensive in the language that
folks use.
For example, there was a group that we were working
with who called their organization an organization that
helps people who are crippled and -- that are crippled and
I think maimed.
And that language is not just old school and makes
you think, Well, that organization should have been around
in the 1800s; but it also says a lot about how that
organization views the folks that they are working with or
the folks that they serve.
And so we provide a technical assistance to folks
all over the country and actually in other countries about
what their brochures should say and using words with
dignity and just thinking more about language.
And so we're very happy to share some of this
information with you today. This presentation that we're
doing for you today, we're going to do it in an abbreviated
fashion. There's a much longer session that we have done
and that we do.
Once again, Liz and I have done this all over
Georgia but also throughout the country. And so if you
want more information, we'd be happy to share it with you.
So why are we here today? We're really here to
master our skills. We know that a lot of you know this
information, but it's not always at the top of our -- or
the tip of our tongue whenever we're expressing the work
that we do or whenever we're thinking about ways to
communicate with folks.
So we're here to master our skills. We're also
here to expand our knowledge. And we see this as a
dialogue. We look forward to learning from you also. So
please feel free to share.
And we're also here to build stronger bridges and
really create inclusive and united communities, not just
within the assistive technology/reuse community or the
assistive technology community in general throughout the
United States but also the disability community and the
general community.
And so realizing that we're all truly peers here.
And we're all learning from each other. We're all going
through this life journey together. And so what is it that
we can do to help each other further along the way?
There's some statistics that we want to share with
you. And one of those -- very important statistics. This
is from the U.S. Census Bureau. And it's an older
statistic, but we know that it is actually true.
And it's that one out of every five Americans has a
disability. So that's 54 million Americans reported some
level of disability in 2005. And that's a large number.
And of these 54 million individuals with
disabilities, they affect their ability to see, hear,
communicate, reason, walk, perform other basic life
functions.
That right there, we're actually quoting the public
law that funds the AT Act. That's in the law. And as we
know, that number grows every day.
And the thing that we want to get people thinking
about is it's amazing -- with all the advances that we had
made in the medical field, it's amazing how many folks are
living, and they're surviving, and they're thriving.
And as they continue to do that, then we're seeing
that, as people age and they age in place, that they really
are -- we are, in the disability community, creating the
largest minority group in America.
This group, without a doubt, it cuts across racial,
ethnic, religious, gender, sexual orientation, sex, age
boundaries. And anyone can become a member of this
minority group. So you, too, if you haven't already
joined, can sign up.
So Liz, I'm going to pass this on over to you for
the next few slides.
LIZ PERSAUD: Thank you, Carolyn.
One of the things I wanted to touch on about the
individuals with disabilities being the largest minority
group and cutting across all sorts of boundaries of life.
We have an acronym that we throw around in the
disability community called TAB, T-A-B. Some of you may
have heard of it. And what it stands for is temporarily
able-bodied, because that's the thing, is that that
54 million is cutting across all sorts of spans of life,
and it doesn't discriminate.
Anyone at any given time can join my population or
join our population, if you will. And so that's the thing,
is you never know who you're dealing with on a daily basis.
So we're hoping that this webinar and some of the
topics that we're covering today will really kind of get
your brain stirring, get your thought process stirring on
how you've related with people with disabilities, how
you're putting out your materials, how you're operating
your program, and how we can always be more effective in
the future as well too.
So this slide says -- it's a guiding principle,
something that we have here with the Pass It On Center that
we truly believe in.
And it says: Disability is a natural part of the
human experience and in no way diminishes the right of
individuals to be independent, enjoy self-determination,
make choices, to go to school, to have a job, to vote, to
eat at the restaurant that they want to eat at, to shop at
the mall that they want to shop at, to just be in society
and be fully included and fully integrated in all aspects
of life.
Again, this is public law from the Tech Act. And I
often say -- Carolyn and I both often say that this is a
beautiful piece of legislation. It's one of my very
favorite pieces of legislation because to me this says that
we are all made the way we are.
Yes, we all have a few differences. But if we just
take a look back and kind of take off those blinders and
those shaded glasses, if you will, we truly have more
similarities than we do differences. And that's one of the
main points that we want to get across today.
So the thing is is that people first language is
the use of words that reflect awareness, dignity, and a
positive attitude about people with disabilities.
Language is continually evolving. We'll talk about
that in just a few moments. But words do make a
difference. They can hurt. The whole little saying of
"Sticks and stones can break your bones, but words may
never hurt," it's not true.
I don't know who came up with that. I never said
it. I never sang it with my peers on the playground. But
it's not true. Words can definitely hurt.
The power of language. Language is absolutely
powerful. It's continually evolving. And that definitely
includes language related to people with disabilities.
And one of the points that we're going to get
across today is that staying current is important, and it's
not necessarily to show that you're being PC or politically
correct but to communicate effectively and with respect.
And with that I'm going to pass it to Carolyn.
CAROLYN PHILLIPS: Just like Liz was saying, it
really is not about being politically correct. I know that
that's one of those things that a lot of people get
frustrated with. I remember back in the '80s people were
like, "Oh, it's so PC," or what have you.
It really is about conveying what you feel about
other folks. As my mama says all the time -- or used to
say all the time is, "What I say and the words I choose to
use to says it say much more about me than they do about
whatever I'm talking about." So language is important, and
it's key.
In 1993 the U.S. Department of Ed and Office of
Civil Rights offered guidelines for referring to people
with disabilities that are consistent with what we now call
person first language or people first language. So we
started seeing it back in 1993.
We also saw this occurring as legislation
started -- people on the federal level started taking words
out of legislation such as the word "handicapped" and some
other words that weren't really accurate in one way, but
they also just weren't very thoughtful in what they were
conveying.
The words -- just like we were saying, the words
used to describe us have power to make us feel valued or
feel demeaned. And it's just a matter of what is it that
you really want to say with that brochure? What is it that
you want to say with the name of your program? What is it
that you want to say in your presentations?
A lot of times people will play upon the pity
factor. And they'll say, "Oh, you've got to give to these
poor crippled people," or, "Oh, goodness" -- I heard it
just the other day on the news.
I saw a commercial that followed the news, but the
news report was sensationalizing that so-and-so was
stricken with a stroke, and they're going to be maimed for
the rest of their life.
And it was heartbreaking the way they were telling
the story, but it was sensationalized. And it was
definitely conveying this image of the individual they were
talking about not one of power and not one of, oh, well, I
bet this person can live independently; I bet this person
can contribute. Instead it was, oh, look at the pitiful
life that this person has now.
And of course I wrote an e-mail to the news and let
them know what I thought about that. But there was a
commercial that followed up right after. And it was for an
organization that was trying to solicit car donations.
And the language they were using again in that
commercial had to do with, if you donate your car, you can
help people who are mentally retarded.
And I was like, wow, I haven't heard that term in a
long time used in the media, especially with the wonderful
campaign that was out there. I don't know how many of you
saw the signs that said that retarded is -- it's not okay
to use that term. Label clothes. Label fruit. Don't
label people.
And just how there's a whole movement trying to get
folks to really think about their language. So it does
matter. It really does matter.
I love this quote right here by Mark Twain. And it
says, "The difference between the right word and the almost
right word is the difference between lightning and a
lightning bug."
Mark Twain I think had it right on with that
because I would much rather tangle with a lightning bug
than lightning. I don't know about you, but I definitely
feel that way.
And I think that a lot of times that is what we're
tangling with. It's that big a difference in how powerful
our language really is.
So value-laden language. I was introduced to this
concept when I was a freshman back in the early '90s back
at the University of Georgia. And I've always liked this
concept.
And basically what it is is just what I was
expressing before, that what you say says more about your
values and how you feel about a person or a topic or a
group of people than it does about that individual or that
group of people. And so it's important to be mindful.
So what you say and write could enhance the dignity
or inadvertently reflect on stereotypes or negative
attitudes.
I often am telling young folks -- because they'll
say things like, "Oh, you're such a retard," or, "That's so
retarded." And I will remind them about, what are you
really saying? Tell me what you really mean by that.
Because it's not a fair statement to make. And just be
mindful of what you're saying and the importance of that.
Some words and phrases don't recognize really the
broad range of capabilities of people with disabilities. I
have learning disabilities. And there are all kinds of
images that I think people, whenever they find that out
about me, when I say, "Oh, I have learning disabilities,"
people come up with all kinds of images in their head as to
what that really means.
And so I end up having to spend, if I feel like it,
time educating people about what that means to me. I'm
dyslexic.
And the other day I was talking to one of my
nephews who's 18, and I said, "Oh" -- he asked me to read
something, and I said, "Oh, I'm dyslexic." And he goes,
"Oh, I'm so sorry." And he came over and gave me a big
hug. And I was like, "What do you think I'm telling you?"
So who knows what images people have in their head
about what different things we say. So it's important that
we pay attention to that.
The other thing that was kind of funny though is he
was telling me how courageous I am. And I haven't been
called courageous in a while for having a learning
disability. But I thought it was pretty funny, especially
knowing that we were going to do this presentation.
People with disabilities don't need or don't want
to be pitied, nor do I have to be seen as courageous or
special just because I have dyslexia or because you can
accomplish daily activities or go to work or get dressed or
what have you.
Liz and I often use the example -- and there's
unfortunately countless examples of this, as you know; one
that just popped up with my nephew. But I've seen it so
many times with my mom, for example.
She has Huntington's Disease, and she's a
wheelchair user. And when we take her out in public,
people will come up to her, and they're saying, "Oh, you're
so brave," and, "It's amazing. Look at you. You're
amazing."
And of course in front of my mom, she just smiles
and nods. But the thing is, is she really brave? Yes,
she's brave. But is she brave for getting dressed and
going out into public? It might be more brave not to be
dressed and go out in the public.
So the thing is we need to be mindful of what is
really brave and what really is amazing. Is it amazing
that somebody with a disability just shows up for work? Is
it amazing that somebody without a disability shows up and
goes to work?
So we just need to be more thoughtful, I think,
about what it is that we really are saying and not use
these sweeping words.
And, Liz, is there anything that you wanted to add
to this? I know you've got all kinds of examples that
would help illustrate this more.
LIZ PERSAUD: I do have all sorts of examples. And
I can probably conduct a whole series of webinars on all of
my examples. I put up an emoticon, Carolyn, because I'm
laughing over here, not being right beside you, laughing at
all your stories and all the things that we've been through
together.
But, yeah, that happens often. I will even be out
with friends, even with my team members, with Carolyn and
Martha, Trish, and Joy. And people will come up to me and
say, "Oh, it's so good to see you out."
And it's like, really? I have a job. And if I'm
not out, I'm not even going to make money and have a
paycheck and just be able to be independent and do all
those things that I need to do just to have a life and to
be living like everyone else.
So it's really interesting how people will kind of
come up and do that. And I do know in my heart of hearts
that people do mean well and all of that.
But it's just something to think about as we are
relating to people, and especially as we have our customers
coming in to our organizations, all the AT reuse programs
across the country.
You never know who you're dealing with on a daily
basis. We want to show that we're friendly and that we're
accepting and that we are empowering people, that we are --
you know, people are coming into our centers, and we're
giving them equipment, or we're giving them brochures and
advertising what we do.
And we're saying, We support you. We're able to
provide you with the tools that you need so you can be
independent; that you can have that confidence when you go
back out into the community, go to work -- you know,
whether it be on the job or playground or at home so you
can just be the best that you are and focus more on your
abilities as opposed to your disability.
So as Carolyn mentioned before, value-laden
language, it says more about our values than it really
truly does about the person that we're relating to, that
we're writing about or speaking about.
The thing is that all staff members should be
sensitive to the language they use in referring to our
customers that come in our doors every day. We need to
focus on referring to the condition instead of the person.
And when we do that, we end up devaluating the person.
People first language is about referring to the
person first and then the disability afterwards, if needed.
Now, granted, in the line of work that we do, we often have
to work with folks to do fittings for chairs, or the issue
of disability comes up.
But just be mindful how you address that, and often
taking the cue of the person that you're speaking with as
well too.
As I mentioned before, we never know who's walking
in our doors at any given time. And as we said in the
beginning of the webinar, folks with disabilities are the
largest minority.
It may not always be visible. It could be
temporary. Some may have more than one disability. Just
because I am sitting in a wheelchair and I roll around and
scoot around town and do my work and scoot around the
office and do things that I do doesn't mean that that's
just my one disability. There could be other things going
on too. So it's just things to be mindful of and to be
open minded of.
It could also be the staff member who has a
disability. Either way, the person is not his or her
disability.
And, Carolyn, I'll pass this on to you.
CAROLYN PHILLIPS: So great points there, Liz, as
always.
The value-laden language, what it really does is it
promotes distance and stereotypes, and it pigeonholes
folks.
There's a fundraiser person, professional
fundraiser that I was talking to not long ago, and she said
that you can raise all kinds of money if you could just get
folks to donate by making them cry.
And I was thinking, What in the world? What in the
world? And she said, "Oh, in your field it would be so
easy to get people to give money because all you have to do
is make them cry."
And I was thinking, I have all kinds of ethical
issues with this. This is totally counterintuitive to who
I am. And as far as I'm concerned, we're in the business
of empowering, not in the business of making everybody cry
and feel pity.
But just the language that she was using. Yes, I
feel certain that she could raise lots of money. She's
been very successful.
I was talking to my dad about this not long ago.
Is this the right way to go? Do you try to raise money by
making people cry?
And he's like, "No. Absolutely not."
And so the thing is, the value-laden language, it
promotes distance and stereotypes. It reduces a sense of
self-worth and power and self-direction.
And so we want to make sure that we are very clear
in what it is that we're trying to do. And when we say
that it's promoting distance, what actually does happen is
there's a "we" versus "they." It's good versus bad, strong
versus weak, high expectations versus low expectations,
sick versus well, superior versus inferior.
And what I mean by that -- I can use an analogy
right now or tell a story right now of my daughter Meera.
It's interesting because, whenever I tell people,
I'm like, "Oh, we have a daughter. Her name is Meera, and
she's from India."
And everybody's like, "Wow. That's so cool."
And I'm like, "Yeah."
And then I talk a little bit more about Meera. And
then sometimes when people meet her, they're like, "Oh, you
didn't tell me that she walks with an AFO," or, "You didn't
tell me that she has cerebral palsy."
And I'm like, "Well, How does that really apply?
Because I was telling you about who Meera is."
And I could tell that it changed their point of
view. Like all of a sudden they have lower expectations of
Meera. They see her as weaker as opposed to strong. The
survivor who was on the streets of India. But if she has
cerebral palsy, then it's a little different perspective.
I see that some folks are saying that the audio is
dropping out. I apologize for that. Unfortunately, that's
the way that some of these webinars go, especially when
we're working with firewalls within agencies. And I truly
apologize for that. And thank you for hanging in there
with us.
We would encourage you to avoid certain words that
really invoke pity or even fear. As I said a little
earlier, when I'm watching the news or listening to
newspapers [sic] or what have you, I hear these things,
these words often.
Just sitting in conversation, especially lately,
I've heard people use words like "abnormal," "afflicted,"
"stricken with."
There are people, aside from my nephew, who have
actually said, "Carolyn suffers from dyslexia."
And the truth is that I do not suffer from
dyslexia. My partner suffers from my dyslexia because she
has to do our bills. The IRS has suffered from my
dyslexia. Other people have suffered from my dyslexia, but
I wouldn't say that necessarily I have done that. I don't
own that.
Yeah, it causes me some struggles. And, yes, it
would probably be easier if I didn't have it, but it
doesn't mean that I suffer from it.
And, Liz, I'm going to turn this to you because you
have a good example for some of these also.
LIZ PERSAUD: The last word on this last -- the
words that we are encouraging folks to stay away from, you
know, think about that in your mind.
Sometimes when we're doing this in front of a live
audience and we're in the same room as people, I'll often
ask people to read that last word. And it's interesting
how over -- you know, the slur of words happening, the
sounds in the room, I'll hear the word [pronounced]
"in-valid" over "invalid." And that's what I see.
I know we often talk about that, Carolyn and I,
about what these words really mean. And we've talked about
that word invalid where people will say -- you know, I've
had family members say, "Oh, that's where my cousin lives,
and there's her daughter who's also an invalid. But, boy,
does she get around town." And it's like what does that
really mean?
Or when people say I'm a victim of muscular
dystrophy or I'm stricken with it. I've had people say --
oftentimes when I was growing up, they'd ask me, "What's it
like to be in a family where all your siblings are normal?"
And I'm like, "Really?" I think sometimes I'll be
looking at my brothers and my sister, and I'll say, "I
think I'm the most 'normal' one of everyone there."
But what do these words mean? So again, it's just
words that we -- as Carolyn said, that they evoke fear;
they evoke pity. And if you're sitting there reading those
words, it's a scary thing.
I mean it's not like it says puppies and kittens
and cupcakes and marshmallows. I mean look at all the
words up there. So definitely words that we encourage
everyone to stay away from.
And I also wanted to ask the question, and anybody
can feel free to type it in, What does the word "handicap"
mean? We often hear that word out in the community. I
know that I'll speak to folks, older generations, and they
sometimes still use that word.
It's a word that we hear often that we know that's
in our history, that's in print, that's out and about when
we're everywhere.
But I encourage everyone to think about that word
"handicap" and what it really means. And for those of you
who don't know, the word "handicap" is actually another
word that invokes pity, fear. It definitely invokes
negative images. And it's an archaic term.
The wonderful thing is that it's no longer used in
any federal legislation whatsoever.
There are many meanings of the legendary H word,
handicapped. But the one that is the most often known and
that we believe in is that it refers to a person with a
disability begging with their cap in their hand. So
basically the word handicapped means beggar.
So when you are out in the community, when you are
putting together your documents for your program, for your
organization, if you often find yourself moving towards
that word, really think about the origin of that word and
what that means.
You'll notice out and about as you're shopping or
just driving around that a lot of -- they'll say --
Handicapped parking signs. Exactly. Thank you,
Jim, for writing that. They should change handicapped
parking signs.
A lot of times it will say "Accessible" now.
And I'm actually going to release the mic for
Carolyn because, Carolyn, I know that you often will go and
speak to businesses that still have signs up that say
"handicap." And I'm wondering if maybe you can give an
example of how you've done that to encourage some folks as
well too.
Actually, before I release it to you, I'll read the
question from Cheryl G.
Cheryl says, "Do you think most people with
disabilities are offended by the word 'handicapped' or just
people who work in the field? I'm asking because I've
heard people with disabilities refer to themselves as
'handicapped.'"
And you're absolutely right, Cheryl. It's kind of
that situation where you'll hear people with disabilities
referring to themselves as handicapped, but some find it
offensive.
Really and truly, it's a word that we generally
want to stay away from because of the meaning of it really
coming to surface and people realizing what it is.
It's something that I stay away from. I know that
our team does. A lot of my friends and family stay away
from.
The truth is that not many people knew what it
meant. It's something that they really and truly grew up
with. And it's kind of those words that, if you grew up
with it, you don't really know any better, if you will.
And oftentimes I'll speak to friends that have the
same exact disability that I do. We'll just be hanging
out, and I'll hear them use that word. And it makes me
just kind of cringe and just grit my teeth.
And I often will explain to them, "Do you know what
that word means? Do you know what it says when you refer
to yourself as a handicap person or a handicap individual?"
And oftentimes they just don't know.
So thank you, Cheryl, for asking that question.
And, Carolyn, I'll release it to you to maybe talk
a little bit about talking to some of the businesses out
there and what that means.
CAROLYN PHILLIPS: Excellent. Thank you, Liz.
Jim, I wanted to address what you said first, that
they should change the signs, the handicapped parking
signs.
I've actually talked to folks that are sign makers
and said, "You know what? You ought to just say
accessible."
What's the big difference when it comes to just
printing a sign? And it's a huge difference when it comes
to people realizing who they are in the world, if you will.
My daughter, for example -- and, Cheryl, this gets
to where your question is. My daughter, she can tell
instantly, if somebody uses the term "handicapped" versus
"a person with a disability," how they're going to treat
her.
A lot of times folks that use the term handicapped,
even though they may not mean to feel this way, they often
are -- they'll baby Meera in some ways, or they'll treat
her differently. And she has gotten to where she just
doesn't even like the word.
It's just -- what it says is that you're not
up-to-date, if you will; that you're -- and it's not about
that language changes necessarily all the time and, oh,
that was so cool ten years ago, and it's not cool now. It
really goes back to that that word in particular is just
not -- it's not a great word.
And every community has those words. Whether
you're talking about folks that are gay or whether you're
talking about folks that are from different cultural
backgrounds or even folks within the feminist movement.
So language obviously is important. And, Cheryl,
I'm so glad that you agree.
And I think that's Carollyn, my friend Carollyn.
Hi.
And I think you're asking, "Is 'disabled parking'
an acceptable use?"
Well, I think it's okay. But once again, it would
be better if you just said "accessible parking." That
would make it even more friendly, and it would make sense
to everyone. People know usually what the blue sign means.
But yeah.
And, Liz, do you have anything you want to weigh in
with that in particular, and then I'll move forward?
LIZ PERSAUD: That's a great question, Carollyn at
Sussex. We think that's Carollyn. And hello.
And, Carolyn Phillips, I definitely agree with you.
"Disabled parking," I'm just kind of on the fence about it.
I just feel that "accessible" is more universal, if you
will. It's a little bit kind of moving into that whole
vibe of universalness and everyone just kind of referring
to themselves as more neutral territory, if you will.
So as Carolyn said, the symbol for accessibility,
the blue sign, is getting more recognition. People know
what that means. So definitely "accessible" is my
particular preference.
This slide here says "Definitions." And on the
left-hand side we have "disability," what that means as in
relation to the word "handicap," if you will.
"Disability. Impairment or limitation, whether
physical, mental or sensory," is what that relates to.
And then "handicap" is more of that "External
condition imposed on a perhaps resulting from a disability.
Stairs are a handicap to someone who uses a wheelchair."
I'm sure that we'll talk about that more in detail.
But we often say that disability is often the consequence
of the environment.
Carolyn and I were just mentioning that to a group
of folks we were speaking with yesterday, that I don't ever
think about my disability until I become -- I enter a
situation or become face-to-face with a situation where the
environment is not accessible to me or I'm unable to reach
something or I can't access a restaurant or I can't be with
my friends or my family or my teammates on the Pass It On
Center team because of the access, because of stairs or no
elevators or curb cut -- there are no curb cuts, if you
will.
So it's more of the environment that proposes that
someone is disabled in my eyes.
These next couple of slides share a little bit of
disability negative language on the left-hand side and
disability neutral.
Over on the left-hand side of this slide it has
"disAbility Negative." So things like "the disabled, the
blind, the deaf" referring to these groups, kind of
clumping them together.
And over on the right-hand side under "disAbility
Neutral," you'll see it says "people with disabilities, the
disability community, the blind community, the deaf
community.
"Crippled, suffers from." We talked about that.
So person, first language, has a disability, is a person
with a disability.
Even "impaired" or "impairment," that word will be
tossed around often. And we just want to say more of
person with a disability, again, has a disability.
So again, more disability negative versus
disability neutral, moving more towards disability neutral
language. So instead of the disabled, the handicapped, the
people with disabilities. Again, we just talked about
accessible parking, accessible entrance.
This one at the end always makes me laugh. Just
because people will come up to me and say, "Oh, goodness,
Liz. What's it like being confined to your wheelchair?"
Or, "There's Liz Persaud. And she's wheelchair bound."
So it just sounds like an awful, awful horror
movie. What does that mean to be confined to a wheelchair
or wheelchair bound? I'm not chained to my wheelchair. I
get out of my wheelchair. I get out, and I sleep in a bed,
and I like to sit on the couch. I love to go swimming.
I don't see my wheelchair as something that I'm
confined to or bound to. It's a tool that I use. It's my
assistive technology that I use every single day to help me
be more independent, to work fully and put my best foot
forward.
So more of that friendly language would be
"wheelchair user" or even "person who uses a wheelchair."
And I'm seeing that Carollyn Kowalski -- hello,
Carollyn -- she said, "It is Carollyn K," and "Hello back.
"I think I would argue that using 'accessible
parking' would not dissuade folks without disabilities from
parking there. Too many of them do now. That's why I
thought 'disabled parking' was more authoritative."
And that's definitely true. And I agree with you.
Carolyn Phillips, do you want to add anything to
that?
CAROLYN PHILLIPS: Yes. Actually two thoughts were
running through my mind.
One would be the disability parking, disabled
parking. Yeah, it's obviously a legal thing for a lot of
folks. You need to have a permit to park in a lot of those
spaces, obviously. And so -- and I think that it's just a
matter of us raising awareness overall.
We here at Tools For Life -- and we'd be happy to
send this out to anyone who wants it -- we have little --
it's actually a little piece of paper that says "Parking
Violation," and on the back it explains why it's important
not to park in accessible spaces if you don't need them and
if you don't have the papers, if you will; if you don't
have the tag and the right to do that.
And it gives more information, and it refers people
back to our website where we have more information about
that.
And I know in Jacksonville and in some other
cities, too, they've started deputizing folks with
disabilities to start giving out tickets to individuals who
are parking, if they don't have a visible display that it's
okay for them -- either the tag on the back of their car or
something hanging from their mirror or whatever is approved
in that state, to be able to give them a ticket.
And I think that's actually pretty empowering. I
know some of my friends who have done that, and they really
like that.
And, yes, I can definitely send that up, Carollyn.
No problem. Would be very happy to do that. We're always
trying to get more people to jump on the bandwagon.
And so anyone that would like those, just let us
know -- let Liz know, actually, and she can get those to
you.
The other thing, going back once again to the
question that you asked, Cheryl G., about the term
"handicap" and how folks use that term, that if they are a
person with a disability, then they use that term even to
refer to themselves.
I've heard that too. And usually, just like Liz
said, she'll try to educate that individual. I do too. A
lot of times people are using language that they have heard
from other folks to develop their own self-identity.
And that's why all that self-determination,
self-esteem, all of those things, that that type of
training is so powerful to help somebody really get an idea
of what are your strengths, and what are your weaknesses,
and who are you really in this world, and are you going to
accept labels that other people give you; or are you going
to make your own way and go that different road, if you
will, you know, your own path, find your own path and your
own identity. So I do think that there's a lot to consider
there.
I was working with some folks that are native
American. And they were telling me that in their tribe
they don't even have a word -- in their native language
they don't even have a word for people that have
disabilities because they see it as just a variation of who
people really are.
They don't see it as something that has to be
labeled and tagged and deemed as different. They just look
at the person and -- it's a very nonjudging way to look at
other individuals. So I really like that way of looking at
that.
So, Cheryl, hopefully you'll get sound back.
It goes on, the disability negative, slow learner,
retarded, developmentally delayed, person with a
disability, person with developmental delays.
Same thing -- a lot of times I've heard these even
recently about dwarf or midget. So you would actually say
little person or a person of small stature.
And then the list continues, especially this last
one that says "homebound." I was talking with a group of
folks that are within the religious community, several of
them. And they were representing churches and synagogues
and other people of faith and communities of faith.
And several of them -- and once again, it was
across denominations and across religion -- they have
homebound programs. And they were like, "Oh, no." They
hadn't thought about that, you know, that that could be
seen as negative. And similar to wheelchair bound.
My mom is classified as homebound, but that doesn't
mean that she's bound to the house. It just means that
it's difficult for her to get out, basically. She's at
home a lot.
And so the whole homebound concept, it does invoke,
once again, pity and other things that come to mind when
you think of folks who are homebound.
So they were talking about, "Oh, we're going to
change our program title for that." And I thought, Well,
that's good. It could just be helping out your neighbor or
helping out other people.
And, yes, you're exactly right, Cynthia. That for
public services, that there is a policy definition that
ties to that, you know, some of these definitions,
actually.
And I think we can define, what does that mean for
someone to be -- for it to be hard for them to get out?
What does that mean? And still provide services but not
necessarily have to use terms that are invoking some other
type of reaction.
We also try not to use generic labels like "the
homebound" or what have you for groups. So we avoid using
whole groups like "the deaf" or "the blind." Oh, they're
part of the blind or the paralyzed and just grouping folks.
I've heard that before. I've heard people actually
say, "Oh, I know so-and-so, and he's a crip," or,
"So-and-so, they are LD," as opposed to it's a person with
a learning disability or they have learning disabilities.
It looks like here -- and I'm trying to read
this -- that -- the word "bedbound." Well, I think it's
along the same line of thought, that you could just say --
and some people would actually say that my mom is bedbound
at this point. And so rather than saying -- I don't think
I've ever used that term with her. As a matter of fact, I
know I haven't. I would say it's just difficult for my mom
to get up out of bed.
If somebody needs to ask, or if they really need
that information -- the truth is, I think a lot of times we
over share in the disability community. I think we give
way, way, way more information than people would want.
I think that HIPAA in some ways is violated like
crazy. I think confidentiality is violated like crazy
within our community. And that can be frustrating because
it's trying to balance educating folks but then also how
much -- when is it too much to share?
Person first language or people first language, it
avoids generic labels, and it really emphasizes abilities,
not limitations.
You can avoid -- and it's important to do this, to
avoids euphemisms that are condescending. I've heard
people, even recently, "So-and-so is blind as a bat." And
I was thinking, I wonder why they're using that, and why is
that okay to say?
And then really and truly I think a lot of the
terms that we use that are so demeaning, most demeaning but
seem to be culturally okay and even the stamp of approval
on are those with folks that are people with mental health
issues.
And so we'll say things like, "Oh, so-and-so is a
lunatic," or, "They're just crazy," or, "That's the
craziest person I've ever seen," or, "So-and-so is a
wackadoo."
And should we really be throwing around terms like
that? It's not really a fair thing to do.
It's also important to avoid implying illness or
suffering. So just like we said, "afflicted," "suffers
from," all of that.
And I am going to turn this right back over to Liz.
Actually, I'm going to cover this slide, and then I'll turn
it right back over to you, Liz.
So it's important to refer to the person first and
then the disability if the disability is important to
mention. So Robert has Parkinson's, or Mary uses a
wheelchair. Sandra has epilepsy. Kelly is paralyzed.
John is deaf or is a person who is deaf.
It was interesting. I had an opportunity to -- I
was talking about my dad the other day about how he would
come home, and at dinner we would talk about friends of his
and coworkers and have no idea -- as we're talking about
people, usually there's some idea you have in your head of
what they might look like or what have you.
But he had this one friend named Oscar. And he
would talk about Oscar, talk about Oscar, how much he
respected Oscar's work, and he's so detail oriented.
And that my dad just would be like, "Oh, Oscar saved this
project for me today, and he did such a great job."
And he might tell us something funny that Oscar
said or something that they were working on together. And
Oscar was more than a coworker. He was really a friend.
And so one day we're driving down the street --
down the highway, actually, up 75, Highway 75 in Atlanta,
and my dad pulls over. He's like, "Oh, there's a car
broken down. I think I'll go help." So he pulls over.
And my dad gets out of the car, and out comes Oscar.
And Oscar is a small person. He's a little person.
And I was about ten years old at the time, and I was taller
than Oscar at that point. And it's not at all what I
thought Oscar looked like.
And I thought it was amazing of my dad -- and it
taught me a big lesson -- and my dad didn't even think to
tell us, "Oh, well, Oscar, he's African-American, and he is
a small person." I mean, we didn't need to know all those
details.
It was super cool, too, because Oscar had this
adapted car, and that was the first adapted car I had ever
seen. So that was very cool.
So referring to the person first. Very, very
important.
And so, Liz, if you'll go ahead and take it away,
that would be great.
LIZ PERSAUD: Thank you, Carolyn.
We have a couple of comments and questions over on
the public-chat area. And I'll read that.
Carollyn K. says, "We have colleagues who say, 'I'm
LD.' And we have colleagues who say it's fine to say
things like 'the deaf groups' or 'the blind students.' How
does that square with the total nonuse of such terms?"
Carollyn K., I'm going to actually read the next
one and answer that related to mobility. And I'm going to
toss it back to Carolyn to answer the one prior, especially
specifically related to the "I'm LD" part, if that's okay
with you, Carolyn Phillips.
So Cynthia says, "You discourage the use of visual
and hearing impairment. What's the preferred alternative
to 'mobility impairment'?"
Again, you're absolutely right. A lot of people
will say "mobility impairment." Oftentimes I just say
"mobility disability" or "someone who uses a chair" or uses
a cane or walker or whatever the assistive technology
device is.
But it's just pulling away from that word
"impairment" because it really does kind of denote the idea
that I'm unable to do anything, or somebody with a mobility
disability is truly unable to do much at all or that they
need assistance with every single thing there in their
lives.
So hopefully that helps. Again, it's just staying
away from "impairment."
So Carolyn Phillips, I'm going to toss it back to
you to answer Carollyn K.'s question about "I'm LD" or the
deaf groups or the blind students.
CAROLYN PHILLIPS: Okay. Thanks, Liz. And
Carollyn, I also have folks who say to me, "I'm LD," or "I
am blind," or what have you. Or they'll say, "I'm LD."
And so often -- it depends on my mood. Sometimes
I'll say, "And I'm Carolyn."
But the thing is that, once again, that's just a
technicality. I think however the person wants to
identify, you know, that's fine.
Sometimes I'll explain it to them, that, "Are you
LD, or do you have a learning disability?" And it gets to
be this kind of fine point of how do you identify and how
do you see yourself? And that becomes, I guess, a deeper
issue, if you will.
And sure enough, my personal observation, but I'd
love to see a study done about this, is the way that people
use language, how much does that really reflect the way
that they really do see themselves? I think it probably
does make a difference.
I was working with somebody not long ago who told
me, they said, "I'm crazy."
And I said, "Well, you are? What do you mean by
that?"
And they're like, "Oh, no. I'm certifiably crazy.
I am really crazy."
And they did mean, I have mental health issues.
But they have been told their whole life that they're
crazy. And it definitely affected their self-esteem and
the way that they identify.
And I thought it was very interesting. And we had
a conversation about, Well, are you crazy, or are you a
person that has major depression? Are you a person that
has mental health issues? And what does that really mean?
So I think you could go a lot deeper with that.
Per usual, you ask those really good questions.
The next slide, it just sums this up.
Using person first language is crucial. It's
putting the person first before the disability. It
describes who a person is, not what a person has.
So when you're creating brochures, when you're
doing public service announcements, when you're advertising
your programs, when you are out there doing presentations
and talking about the people that you work with -- even
terms like -- and, Carollyn, I misread this at first when
you said the deal groups.
I was in an IEP meeting the other day, and a
teacher told me, "I have to deal with kids that are
retarded all day, and I have to deal with kids that are" --
and she goes, "And I don't even know the right terms."
And I was like, "No, you don't. Maybe it's time to
retire."
And the whole idea of "dealing with," what does
that even mean? I would say that I work with the
disability community. I'm a part of that community, but I
also work with folks with disabilities.
And so there's all kinds of ways that we can say
that really do express how we really feel about the folks
that we are working with and the folks that we are charged
with serving.
LIZ PERSAUD: This is a poem called "See Me" by
Madeleine Alston. And we often share this with the groups
that we're speaking to on this subject matter. To me it's
just very poignant, and it speaks to all the things that
we're talking about today. But I'll read this for
everyone. "See Me" by Madeleine Alston.
"You look, but you don't see me. You see a crutch.
A bald head. A scar. A disease. An object of pity. You
don't see the person. The determination. The fear. The
vitality. The passion for living. The capacity for love.
Open your eyes and look without prejudice. Look beyond my
leg. Look beyond my illness. Look into my world. See the
many pieces, not just one. A complete person. Open your
eyes and see me."
I absolutely think this is a beautiful poem. And
really and truly, I mentioned earlier at the beginning of
the webinar, we're talking about relating to people with
disabilities.
But the thing is is that we're all people. And if
you really read this poem and you really think about the
words, we all want people to see us for who we are. We've
all got some "issue" that we're dealing with every day,
whether it's you're just tired today, you're in a grumpy
mood or something's going on in your life that's just not
vibing on the positive level, if you will.
But we all just want people to really focus on us
as the person, to see us for all the great things that we
have to bring to the table.
So again, "See Me" by Madeleine Alston, a very
beautiful poem that just speaks to everything that we are
really pointing out today.
So we've got a couple of points that were put in
the public chat. And let me actually read some of these
for the group. Oh, a lot of great things. I'm scrolling
up. Okay.
Carollyn K. again asked, "What are your thoughts
about using the abbreviation PWD with colleagues, not the
general public?"
And again, for those of you who don't know, PWD is
person or people with disabilities.
Carollyn, it's kind of one of those acronyms that's
out there. To be honest with you, I find myself, whenever
I'll see the acronym, if I'm creating some paperwork, if
we're doing a training, or if we're just creating some
documents to share with groups or committees that we're on,
I often spell it out just because it's kind of a personal
thing for me.
But again, there are so many acronyms in the
disability community that it's kind of one of those things,
I guess if you're taking quick notes, it's up to personal
preference. But that's just me, Liz, kind of giving my two
cents there with that.
And again, we just always want to be mindful of
spelling out those acronyms and being able for folks to
understand that fully and really what that means.
Let's see. We've got Gigi Taylor. Hello, Gigi.
Gigi Taylor is part of the Tools For Life advisory council.
She says, "Is this helpful, the International
Classification of Functioning Disability and Health, ICF?"
And I see you've got a lot of great things here of
what the ICF defines disability as. That's functioning in
multiple life areas. So I can definitely include this in a
PowerPoint. We'll actually put this PowerPoint on the
website. And I can create a slide with these definitions
from the International Classification of Functioning
Disability and Health.
And also Kimberly, again, is transcribing this.
And we can get this information up there. We'll also
include this in our knowledge base as well too.
But it's got some great information including
things like "Disability is seen as a result of an
interaction between a person with a health condition and
the person's contextual factors, environmental factors, and
personal factors." So some really great information.
Thank you, Gigi, for including that.
And thank you, Cheryl, for saying, "Nice poem." We
really appreciate that.
I'm actually going to be -- I think Carolyn
Phillips said that her computer is giving her some trouble.
So let me just release the mic for one second.
Carolyn, are you able to connect with us, or are
you gone?
CAROLYN PHILLIPS: Hi. I'm back as Martha. So
what I'll need is, Liz, if you'll just go ahead and flip
the slides.
Every now and again here at the Department of Labor
they shut down our computers and do some updates. So very
untimely, but they're doing that right now with mine. So
anyway, so I've jumped over here to Martha.
So the next slide here -- and I like this, that
it's really about emphasizing abilities, not limitations.
And so when writing about folks with disabilities, it's
important to show them as active participants in society.
One of the things when we first started the program
ReBoot, we were very, very -- took it to heart that we
needed to include -- and we actually practice what we
preach where we hired folks with disabilities to be a part
of that. Obviously I was a part of that program. And very
successful reuse program.
And we talked about "Nothing about us without us,"
that this program was operated by folks with disabilities,
and it is for people with disabilities.
And that's not to say people without disabilities
couldn't participate. Obviously we want to work side by
side. But I think it was that whole doing-it-for-ourselves
type of thing. So very, very important to look at that.
And of the folks with disabilities between the ages
of 21 and 64 in this study, 49 percent were actively
employed, which is great. So it's important that we
recognize those things and see, you know, how that can
really help raise awareness and get people thinking about
people with disabilities not as people to pity but also
people who have a lot to contribute.
So I would encourage everyone -- and I say it all
the time, that we need to practice what we preach. It's
very important that we do hire folks with disabilities, and
that, as we operate programs for people with disabilities,
that we actually -- it's that whole thing of "Nothing about
us without us."
So, Liz, I'm going to turn this back over to you
for just a couple more minutes. And then I'll jump right
back on with you.
LIZ PERSAUD: Thank you, Carolyn.
I wanted to let you know that -- I know you're on
Martha's computer, but it's not allowing me to flip the
slides. So I'm going to try refreshing and see what that
does.
Does anyone have any questions or any comments that
they want to add while we're trying to figure this out?
CAROLYN PHILLIPS: We would also love to hear from
y'all how you have incorporated person first language, or
have you noticed differences whenever you use that language
as opposed to language that may not be as empowering?
And I know many of you are operating programs as
I'm looking through the list. So if you could share with
us some of your experiences, that would be helpful too.
And it looks like Carollyn Kowalski, "Ain't
technology grand?"
"Yes. I hear ya." It definitely -- "It is when it
works. That's for darn sure."
So I think that it's exciting to see how folks have
been able to evolve in their programs and seeing how
language has changed.
And people often ask me the question of "Do you
think that our language is going to get to a point where
'person with disability' is going to be wrong or bad or
what have you?"
And, yeah, it may. As we said, language is always
evolving. But the thing is is that there's a connection
between language and -- there's a huge connection between
the language we use and our actions. And then our actions,
obviously -- there's a connection between our actions and
attitudes.
And so there are a couple of things we are going to
talk to you about etiquette, not so much because you don't
do these things, but more because we want you to -- and I
think that a lot of times we don't do this where we embrace
the role of leader.
Just because we work in the disability community, a
lot of people do watch what we do, and they see us as
leaders, and they see us as the folks that they should
copy.
And so it's very important that you show the best
use of language, that you show etiquette, all of those
things.
So as we were talking here about don't use
euphemisms to describe a disability. It's important not to
do that. And so like things -- I've even heard things like
"Somebody's handy capable." That one in particular -- that
drives me a little bit crazy, somebody's handy capable,
because it's making light of something or making something
kind of cutesy that really doesn't need to be cutesy.
And so mental problem, "they're different,"
"special." I've heard that so many times throughout my
life that, "Oh, I'm special." And I'm like, Am I special,
or do I just have a learning disability?
You know, and then "physically inconvenienced."
And I've got to tell you, I think a lot of folks would
argue that it's much more than an inconvenience. And so we
don't want to necessarily approach it from that standpoint.
And we can move to the next slide. And good job,
team, in moving us along.
There's a picture up here that's showing obviously
a lot of different folks. And the thing is it's
reiterating the point that not all folks with
disabilities -- it's not all visible.
Often people are surprised whenever I tell them
that I have a disability. And I know that, knowing a lot
of folks in this picture, that there are all kinds of folks
in here that -- we have various abilities and disabilities.
And so we really need to appreciate the
accomplishments of all folks with disabilities. But it's
not about being heroic or super human.
Kerry Morgan is in this picture. And Kerry Morgan,
somebody who I definitely respect and is good friends with
several of the folks here on our staff. And she's a
paralympic athlete, really accomplished, working on her
doctorate. And, yeah, I would say she's super human.
And I look over there, and I see Liz Persaud, who
has done all kinds of amazing things with her life,
literally amazing things, has won a lot of awards and
really changed the way that folks view life in general.
And so definitely super human and heroic.
But it doesn't mean that, just because somebody
uses a wheelchair, that they are. So, once again, just
thinking about this and taking it into consideration.
Liz, anything you would like to add to this?
LIZ PERSAUD: Thank you, Carolyn, for saying those
kind words. I really appreciate that.
You know, and I do. I do work really hard. The
last paragraph here says "Doing so raises the expectation
that all people with disabilities should be high
achievers."
I tell you what -- and I'll be honest with everyone
out there -- it does put a lot of pressure when people say,
"Oh, it's so great that Liz gets out today," or, "Look at
all the work that Liz has done, and she just does so much,
and God bless her for just sitting in that chair and just
working with the Pass It On Center."
But the thing is that I love my job, and I would
more than likely be doing it whether I'm in a chair or not
in a chair.
But oftentimes it does -- and I've spoken to
people, friends and other colleagues, about the pressure
that it can put on you because it does feel that you have
to always really put that best -- we're always putting our
best foot forward, but it's the pressure of kind of being
held to that standard of can I have a bad day, or can I
make a mistake, and things like that.
And the things is I do work -- we all work really
hard to do great things and to really make a name for
ourselves in the community. But the thing is is that name
for me is Liz Persaud. It's not, "Oh, that girl in the
wheelchair that's with the Pass It On Center," or, "Liz
Persaud, the person who was able to join the webinar today
despite having all sorts of issues with transportation and
doing this and doing that."
That's not what it's about. It's just seeing me
and other people with disabilities, again, for their
abilities and the work that they are doing every day that's
just -- the everyday work in this community.
CAROLYN PHILLIPS: I was just going to add and as
we move on to the next little piece here. Liz and I were
at a conference, and there was a person who's very well
respected, very well known, who was talking up there at the
conference.
And she made this statement about how, "Oh, if you
want somebody who's never late to work, if you want
somebody who will never be sick, who will never call in
sick, who will always be loyal, who will be with you every
day, every step of the way, then you need to hire a person
with a disability."
And I looked at Liz, and we were both laughing.
And I said, "Good Lord. I think we ought to be fired, and
we'll get some of those people," because it's just not
realistic. And it was unfair to say that that's who we are
as people. So it was just kind of a funny aside.
So making the connection here. There's a huge
connection between our language and our attitudes. And
then of course our language and attitudes lead to our
actions.
If you use the term "handicap," you may or may not
view people with disabilities as less than. Of course
that's a term that's been around forever.
But if you think of people as crazy, you're sure
not going to hire people that you think are crazy. But if
you think -- if you get to know that person and you
realize, oh, it's a person just like everybody else,
manifest differently, they might have mental health issues,
well, okay, then you might give them a chance. You might
hire them. Or you might welcome them into your family or
what have you. So very important.
And it leads directly to our work culture and our
environment. I think there's a lot of fear whenever people
don't understand that folks may have mental health issues
or what have you. So just pay attention to that.
And we'll go on to the next slide with this closing
thought, that a change in language and attitude can really
change everything.
Etiquette and attitudes. Once again, I think that
a lot of times people pay attention to even the slightest
of gestures. Shaking somebody's hand, absolutely welcomed
for most folks with disabilities. And it's important to do
that if you are a person who shakes hands.
If you are not a person who shakes hands, then
obviously don't. You don't have to go out of your way to
shake hands or shake somebody's artificial limb or what
have you.
And it's very acceptable to say to somebody who's
blind, "I'm extending my hand. I shake hands." I say
stuff like that often.
It's important to be consistent. So however you
would typically interact, then go ahead and interact that
way. Very, very important.
And we'll move on to the next slide.
Another piece that we want to think about is
looking directly at the individual. And once again, I
can't even tell you how many times I have to tell people
and educate folks about this.
And once again, we know that a lot of y'all feel
the same way that we do. But it's important that you help
us, that we all work together to raise awareness about
this.
But it's this concept of looking at the individual
directly that you're addressing. There are many times that
I'll be out to dinner with Liz, and the person will come
up, and they'll say, "Hey, what does she want to eat?"
And I'm like, "Well, she's going to have to read
the menu to me first before I can even tell you what I
want."
So it's kind of this crazy thing where folks do.
Just because I'm walking around doesn't mean that I can
read the menu. Or just because I can drive doesn't mean
that I can read the GPS or the directions.
So it's important to look directly at the
individual. If there's an interpreter there, look at the
individual that you're talking with, not the interpreter.
And it's a-okay to say things like "See you later"
to somebody who's blind or, "Hey, do you want to go for a
walk?" Liz and I go for walks all the time. As a matter
of fact, it's one of my favorite things to do.
And so it's just one of those things that I think
that sometimes we do get a little overboard about language.
And we don't want any of this to be a barrier to you
actually talking with folks.
I was in an IEP meeting not long ago, and it was
very frustrating because everybody kept talking about the
individual that's in the IEP meeting instead of looking at
the individual that the whole IEP meeting was about who was
present.
And I kept addressing this young man. And he
finally said in the middle of the meeting, "You know
Carolyn is the only one who looks at me and sees me as a
person." And I was like, Oh, goodness. So I think a lot
of people would think he wasn't aware of that. But sure
enough, he definitely was.
So we can move on to the next slide.
So disability. It really is a matter of
perception, as Martina Navratilova said. If you can do
just one thing well, you're needed by someone. And that's
for sure.
I see that manifest again and again. And I do
believe that whatever our different beliefs are on how we
got here, that we are all blessed with gifts. And so
whatever that gift is, do that one thing, do it really
well, and contribute. Everyone has something to
contribute.
So be patient. Take time to communicate. It's
incredibly frustrating. My daughter uses an alternative
augmentative communication device. And people are hardly
ever patient with her. They just rush ahead, and they're
always guessing at what she's going to say. And it's very
frustrating.
She's incredibly patient to put up with that. And
I'm often trying to educate people just to take time.
Don't finish people's sentences. And don't assume that you
know what somebody's going to ask or what you're talking
about. Always ask when in doubt.
And obviously be natural in your language. I know
that all of us really and truly want to talk to each other
with respect and dignity. And that needs to be portrayed
in our PSAs and in our presentations and in the way that we
pass out information about our programs as we're developing
our programs and all of that.
We can move on to the next slide.
And, Liz, if you want to take the next slide, that
would be great.
LIZ PERSAUD: Thank you, Carolyn. Great job.
So begin with making the connection. These last
two slides really tie in the kind of -- us as service
providers as having our AT reuse programs across the
country and as we're representing and as we're serving
people with disabilities.
The thing here is it says "If employers believe
adults with disAbilities have or could learn valuable job
skills, we wouldn't have an estimated 70 percent
unemployment rate of people with disAbilities." 70 percent
unemployment rate. It's absolutely unacceptable.
And we're constantly just doing work to really
change that number every day. But we've got to be the ones
that are listening to people, that are believing that
everyone can work, and it's all about accommodations and
using assistive technology and using reuse pieces of
assistive technology as well too.
And "If merchants saw people with disAbilities as
customers with money to spend, we wouldn't have so many
inaccessible stores, theaters, restrooms, and more." And
that's very true.
Often when Carolyn and I do this talk -- I know
it's a belief that I absolutely love about Carolyn and many
of my friends across the board too.
But if Carolyn -- even though she doesn't use a
mobility device to navigate, but if she comes across a
restaurant or another facility that has steps and isn't
fully accessible, she won't pay money to that merchant, to
that place of business because what does that say?
That says that we're putting that place in
business, and they're not accepting of everyone in our
society. And that's really something that we've got to
move away from.
How can we be supporting these businesses and --
whether it be restaurants or theaters or stores or anything
like that, that doesn't accept everyone in our community
together?
And if the service system, if we as organizations
out there and agencies working with people with
disabilities, if we started identifying people with
disabilities as customers instead of clients or
consumers -- that word "consumer" drives me crazy at times
because what I feel like people are saying about me is that
I'm consuming everything around me.
It's not my meal. It's not my dinner. I'm not
chomping away at the hooves of everything. But really is
that what it means, is that I'm just eating up every single
thing that I need out there as opposed to recipients.
And perhaps it would begin to meet a person's real
needs, like inclusion and friendships, instead of trying to
remediate problems.
And that's what it is. People with disabilities
don't need to be fixed. People with disabilities aren't
broken. But people with disabilities just want to be seen
as real people living as they are every day in our
community, in our society.
And we can move on to the next slide.
And the thing is is that people with disabilities,
it's the whole thing that Carolyn mentioned earlier about
learned helplessness.
We had somebody mention earlier about people
referring to themselves -- I think it was Cheryl that
mentioned it earlier. People with disabilities referring
to themselves as handicapped.
And it's because of that learned language that they
grew up with or they heard people referred to them as. And
what does that really mean?
So "If people with disabilities and family members
saw themselves as a first-class citizen who can and should
be fully included in all areas of society, they might focus
on what's really important: Living a real life in a real
world, enjoying ordinary opportunities and experiences, and
dreaming big dreams (like people without disabilities),
instead of living in a special life in a disability world
where low expectations, isolation, segregation, poverty and
hopelessness are the norm."
And that's the thing that we're just trying to get
across. It's just really focusing on that language,
focusing more on abilities as opposed to disabilities. And
getting people with disabilities -- encouraging them to see
themselves as people who can, you know, be in our society
and who can give back to society.
I was at a function for one of the -- a big gala
here in Atlanta. And I remember sitting there, and there
were all these business folks raising all this money for
this particular organization.
And somebody on stage said, "We just want all these
folks to be tax-paying citizens." And I just couldn't
believe what I was hearing because it made me feel like
they were seeing folks with disabilities in the room who
were there contributing, who were there giving their
hard-earned money to this particular charity, if you will,
as not tax-paying citizens.
And I pay my taxes. Just finished filing taxes a
couple of weeks ago. And working hard to do so. So that's
the thing is just seeing individuals as they are.
And we can move on to the next slide.
And, Carolyn Phillips, do you have anything that
you want to add to that?
CAROLYN PHILLIPS: Yes. Actually, as we're
wrapping up, I just wanted to say that we are definitely
here to help. And if you do need our help as you move
forward, if you have any questions, we definitely want to
be there for you.
And we've looked at lots of different materials
that people have produced. We've looked at websites that
people have put together just to help out. Not just
looking at the language so much, but it's also how we
convey the message because it is powerful. And it's always
good to get other folks' perspective on it.
People feel better, obviously, about us and the
service we provide when we treat everyone with dignity and
respect. That's what all of us want.
We'll move on to the next couple of slides, and
we'll wrap up.
And it looked like -- yes. Kerry Morgan is a good
friend -- and I'm glad that you said that -- good friend of
yours. And I totally agree that she would be mortified to
hear folks refer to her as a hero or super human.
And I think that that's obviously important for all
of us. Just like I don't want somebody telling people that
I suffer from dyslexia or what have you.
So William James said this very, very well, that
"The greatest discovery of my generation is that human
beings can alter their lives by altering the attitudes of
their mind."
I think of that often, that it really is a gift
that we have that we can change, and we can grow, and we
can develop, and we can help other folks change and grow
and develop, and that we really can alter our lives by
altering the attitudes of our minds.
So the next slides, please.
And this is just one other piece here that we have
discussed a bit. But it's true, and it's worth repeating.
It's that disability really is often a consequence of the
environment.
And bearing that in mind, it's important for us to
break down those barriers, whether they be stairs when we
really need a ramp or whether it be something that's paper
that needs to be in electronic format, or whether it's a
word that needs to be changed to something more friendly,
or whether it's an attitude that we need to really look at.
So disability is really a consequence of the environment.
And, Gigi, I sure do appreciate you sharing with us
more definitions. That's awesome, and we'll definitely
incorporate more of that.
Next slide, please.
So if y'all have any questions, as we said, we're
here to help. That's -- I've already gotten some messages
from behind the scenes saying that this has been helpful.
We hope it has been.
And does anyone have any questions that they'd like
to ask?
And we'll move on to the next slide which should
have information about our survey.
And I'll pass this over to Liz.
And thank you, Ann. I appreciate that. And thank
you all very much for hanging in there with us.
And we're very excited about this webinar in
particular because I think it is one of those foundation
webinars and one of those foundation conversations that we
need to have.
And so I appreciate your openness and willingness
to also help us spread the news and the message about how
we do need to change and be more thoughtful about our
language even as it evolves.
So, Liz, what would you like to add to this as we
close?
LIZ PERSAUD: Thank you, Carolyn. I really
appreciate you doing this with me. And I love
co-presenting this topic with you, even if it is from a few
miles away.
Again, everyone, we're here for you. Please let us
know if you have any questions.
Please fill out our survey. Again, that really
helps us to offer these credits and to continue putting
these webinars on for you. I put the link in the
public-chat area. So again, it will take you less than
five minutes to do that.
We wanted to say a special thanks to Life Span
Institute, Kathie Snow, and Paraquad, Inc. We were able to
use some of their information as we were kind of putting
our thoughts together about disability is natural and
people first and language.
Next slide, please.
And again, just always get in touch with us if you
have any questions at all. Carolyn and my -- our e-mail
address is there. You can also e-mail
info@passitoncenter.org. We're definitely here for you.
Again, we appreciate your time. This has been a
wonderful webinar. We really appreciate everyone putting
in your comments, asking questions, and really being in
sync with us today and just giving such great, positive
feedback.
Again, this webinar will be archived. So give us
about three to four weeks, and we'll get that up on the
Pass It On Center website.
In the meantime, we'll go ahead and post this
PowerPoint so you'll be able to access that.
We also wanted to let you know that we'll be
turning this webinar into a training package and putting
that on the Pass It On Center knowledge base. So if you
would like to use this as a shell, as a template, a guide,
if you will, to recreate this presentation, you'll be able
to access that information on the Pass It On Center webinar
page. And also feel free just to get in touch with us if
you have any questions.
So thanks everyone again. And we'll see you next
month for another great webinar. Take care.
CAROLYN PHILLIPS: Excellent. And, Liz, once
again, as always, great job.
And, Martha, thank you for letting me jump in. You
can be my avatar. Thank you. Or I'm your avatar; however
that works. But thank you for letting me assume your
identity for the rest of the webinar.
And thank you all for the thumbs-up.
Once again, we're here to help. So be in touch.
And we look forward to working with you even more. Take
care.